2022 – tim anderson (ss), liam hendriks (p)
2021 – tim anderson (ss), liam hendriks (p), lance lynn (p), carlos rodón (p)
2019 – jose abreu (1b), lucas giolito (p), james mccann (c)
2018 – #jose abreu (1b)
2017 – avisil garcia (de)
2016 – jose quintana (p), chris sale (p)
2015 – chris sale (p)
2014 – jose abreu (1b), alexei ramirez (ss), chris sale (p)
2013 – *jesse crain (p), chris sale (p)
2012 – adam dunn (1b), paul konerko (1b), jake peavy (p), chris sale (p)
2011 – paul konerko (1b), carlos quentin (de)
2010 – paul konerko (1b), matt thornton (p)
2009 – buehrle brand (p)
2008 – joe crede (3b), carlos quentin (de)
2007 – bobby jenks (p)
2006 – paul konerko (1b), jim thome (de), jose contreras (p), jermaine dye (de), mark buehrle (p), bobby jenks (p), @a.j. pierzynski (c)
2005 – #mark buehrle (p), jon garland (p), paul konerko (1b), @scott podsednik (de)
2004 – esteban loaiza (p)
2003 – #esteban loaiza (p), magnglio ordonez (de), carl everett (de)
2002 – mark buehrle (p), paul konerko (1b)
2001 – Maglio Ordóñez (de)
2000 – James Baldwin (p), Ray Durham (2b), Magglio Ordóñez (de)
1999 – Maglio Ordóñez (de)
1998 – durham lightning (2b)
1997 – #*frank thomas (1b), albert belle (de)
1996 – #*frank thomas (1b), roberto hernandez (p)
1995 – #frank thomas (1b)
1994 – #frank thomas (1b), wilson alvarez (p), jason bere (p)
1993 – jack mcdowell (p), frank thomas (1b)
1992 – jack mcdowell (p), robin ventura (3b)
1991 – carlton fisk (c), ozzie guillén (ss), jack mcdowell (p)
1990 – ozzie guillén (ss), bobby thigpen (p)
1989 – #harold baines (dh)
1988 – *ozzie guillén (ss).
1987 – harold baines (de)
1986 – harold baines (de)
1985 – #carlton fisk (c), harold baines (de)
1984 – richard dotson (p)
1983 – kittle rum (de)
1982 – #carlton fisk (c)
1981 – #carlton fisk (c), britt burns (p)
1980 – farmer ed (p)
1979 – lemon chet (de)
1978 – lemon chet (de)
1977 – #richie zisk (de)
1976 – rich gossip (p)
1975 – bucky dent (ss), rich gossage (p), jim kaat (p), jorge orta (2b)
1974 – #dick allen (1b), wilbur wood (p), *ed herrmann (c).
1973 – #dick allen (1b), pat kelly (of) (kelly replaced allen due to injury)
1972 – #dick allen (1b), carlos may (de), wilbur wood (p)
1971 – melton account (3b)
1970 – #luis aparicio (ss)
1969 – carlos may (de)
1968 – tommy john (p), duane josephson (c)
1967 – tommie agee (de), ken berry (de), joel horlen (p), gary peters (p)
1966 – tommie agee (de)
1965 – eddie fisher (p), bill skowron (1b)
1964 – Gary Peters (p), Juan Pizarro (p)
1963 – nellie fox (2b), juan pizarro (p)
1962 – luis aparicio (ss), jim landis (de)
1961 – nellie fox (2b), billy pierce (p), luis aparicio (ss), ray herbert (p), roy sievers (1b)
1960 – #minnie minoso (de), luis aparicio (ss), nellie fox (2b), sherm lollar (c), gerry staley (p), early wynn (p), al blacksmith (of)
1959 – #luis aparicio (ss), #nellie fox (2b), #early wynn (p), sherm lollar (c), billy pierce (p)
1958 – #luis aparicio (ss), #nellie fox (2b), sherm lollar (c), billy pierce (p), early wynn (p)
1957 – #nellie fox (2b), minnie minoso (de), billy pierce (p)
1956 – #nellie fox (2b), #billy pierce (p), sherm lollar (c), jim wilson (p)
1955 – #nellie fox (2b), #billy pierce (p), chico carrasquel (ss), sherm lollar (c), dick donovan (p)
1954 – #minnie minoso (de), #chico carrasquel (ss), sandy consuegra (p), nellie fox (2b), bob keegan (p), sherm lollar (c), virgil trucks (p), *george kell (3b), *ferris fain (1b)
1953 – #chico carrasquel (ss), #billy pierce (p), nellie fox (2b), ferris fain (1b), minnie minoso (of)
1952 – #eddie robinson (1b), nellie fox (2b), minnie minoso (de)
1951 – #carrasquel boy (ss), #nellie fox (2b), jim busby (de), randy gumpert (p), minnie minoso (de), eddie robinson (1b)
1950 – rae scarborough (p)
1949 – #cass michaels (2b)
1948 – joe haynes (p)
1947 – luke appling (ss), rudy york (1b)
1946 – luke appling (ss)
1944 – #thurman tucker (de), orval grove (p)
1943 – luke appling (ss)
1942 – edgar smith (p)
1941 – luke appling (ss), thornton lee (p), edgar smith (p)
1940 – #luke appling (ss)
1939 – luke appling (ss), ted lyons (p)
1938 – #mike kreevich (de)
1937 – luke sewell (c), *monty stratton (p).
1936 – #luke appling (ss), #rip radcliff (de), vern kennedy (p)
1935 – #al simmons (de)
1934 – #al simmons (de), jimmy dykes (3b)
1933 – #al simmons (de), jimmy dykes (3b)
# selected as headline
@Winner of the online fan vote
* injured, did not play